Mommy Wars on ABC

My daughter, Molly, brought this to my attention. I read it, needless to say, with a big grateful smile. Glad to be older. Glad not to have to make that decision again.

I read some of the comments from mothers about working and staying home. What was most apparent was the division. Yet what young mothers don't understand is that it's always been that way. To work or not to work - that is the question. Whether tis nobler in the mind to suffer the slings and arrows of the work world, or by opposing, stay at home. To die? To sleep?

As times change so do decisions. Years ago, we were able to rear a family on $150. a week. Today, that's impossible without help. Years ago, there was a neighborhood that supported stay at home moms. Today neighborhoods are empty, and those who stay home have to find alternative groups.

Each woman is different and perceives her family differently from the next woman. Some women fly into motherhood with their sleeves rolled up and a hungry look on their faces - "more please." Other women gratefully pass the baby to whomever will hold him or her. Some women find the world a much more exciting place than home, and others find home the most exciting place in the world. No two women view "home" the same way.

But to brutally say, however, that educated moms who opt to stay at home and rear their families are a detriment to themselves, society and their homes is out in space. What can she possibly think of "the home?"

Does she mean that undereducated women don't matter because this law professor is only concerned with those who have "mastered the masters?" Does she discriminate if someone doesn't have degrees?

My wedding was in the NY Times. Big deal. They probably lied. At that time, I had a high school diploma. I stayed home. I suppose I didn't matter. Now I matter because sometime between the NY Times and the Evansville Courier, I got me an education! That simply doesn't make sense.

And as for the children, a lesser life is in the eyes of the beholder. A child growing up in a log cabin out in the woods learning about nature and wild things at the hand of her mother who grows up to be a scientist has a great beginning. As well, a child who grows up with loving parents who work and share his life with loving teachers will also do well.

This law professor needs a clue. Muzzle!

From ABC News "Mommy Wars - to Work or Stay at Home

Feb. 22, 2006 — An alarming number of college-educated women are leaving the work force to stay at home and raise their children, a trend that is a tragedy not only for the mothers, but ultimately their children and women as a whole.

So said law professor and working mom Linda Hirshman in a 2005 article for American Prospect magazine that has ignited an intense debate among mothers.

Census figures show 54 percent of mothers with a graduate or professional degree no longer work full time. In 2003 and 2004 Hirshman interviewed about 30 women whose wedding announcements had appeared in The New York Times in 1996 and who had had children. Five of the women were working full time, and 10 were working part time. The rest were not working at all.

"We care because what they do is bad for them, is certainly bad for society, and is widely imitated, even by people who never get their weddings in the Times," Hirshman wrote. "This last is called the 'regime effect,' and it means that even if women don't quit their jobs for their families, they think they should and feel guilty about not doing it."

Hirshman also said educated women choosing to stay home was bad for them as individuals.
"A good life for humans includes the classical standard of using one's capacities for speech and reason in a prudent way, the liberal requirement of having enough autonomy to direct one's own life, and the utilitarian test of doing more good than harm in the world," Hirshman wrote.

"Measured against these time-tested standards, the expensively educated, upper-class moms will be leading lesser lives."

The Other Side

Faith Fuhrman has a master's degree in nursing, but chooses to stay home with her children.
"The job I was in when I had, first had my child, I couldn't have done it," Fuhrman said. "I was working 14 hours a day. I was on call."

When Debbie Klett became a mother, she quit her job in ad sales and started a magazine called Total 180 so she could work from home and spend more time with her children.

"For me, I feel it is vital to be there for my children every day, to consistently tend to their needs, to grow their self-esteem, and to praise them when they're right, guide them when they're not, and to be a loving, caring mom every minute of the day," Klett said.

Klett acknowledged there were consequences to her choice to stay at home. To save money, her family has given up cable, does not go out to dinner, and does not go on vacations.

"We made tremendous financial sacrifices for me to be able to stay home with my children, and I wouldn't trade that for the world," Klett said.

What About the Children?

Hirshman argues that Klett's children would be fine if she worked outside the home. Statistically there is no difference in the happiness levels of the children whose mothers work and the children whose mothers stay at home, she said.

Deborah Skolnick agrees. She is a magazine editor who will not give up her job and feels working is a good example for her children, and helps them in other ways.

"I think my kids are as well-behaved and as well-socialized, if not better, than a lot of a fair number of at-home moms," Skolnick said. "I see at-home moms whose children won't separate from them, won't go to school, cry at the door. My children have learned, from an early age, that Mommy will be back. So they kiss me and they say goodbye."

Fuhrman asked her 13-year-old son what he thought was the benefit of having a stay-at-home mom.

"He said, 'Well, I really like to come home every day and finding you here,'" Fuhrman said.

"But on the other hand, my daughter says to me, 'Mommy, when I grow up, I'm gonna get a job at your magazine, and I'm gonna sit at the same desk as you and we're gonna be on the same magazine together until we die,'" Skolnick said. "And that makes me kind of happy."

Tune in to "Good Morning America" Thursday when the "Mommy Wars" continue.